blackout wrote on Aug 2
nd, 2011 at 4:27am:
Okay so tell me this if your in a 9 out 12 guild run and you pull something and your guildy wants it wants it and the pug guy wants it are you going to give it for roll or just give it to guildy me i will give it to guildy that is how all guilds work.
FIFY
And you are free to do so as it fell in your name.
But the question then becomes: Does your guildy have any more right to it than the pugger? The pugger did his part to help complete the raid, just like your guildy did. Putting it up for roll is the respectable thing to do.
If it's an item that you know your friend/guildy REALLY wants, or has had a hard time finding, then the decision to pass it could be easier for a pugger to accept. If you passed it only because he's your guildy, then that was a dick move.
But again, you were within your rights to pull a dick move because it was yours to begin with.
The bottom line is that it all boils down to karma and reputation. Your reputation with puggers in your group, from my personal experience, is complete shit.